Peaches and Cream was born at the Leonard Chincoteague Pony Farm on Chincoteague. Her sire is the prolific Tuffer Than Leather who sired many Misty ponies out of Misty family mares. She was sold to the Rice family of Massachusetts as a weanling. Peaches was bred to Misty's Irish Mist twice and is the dam of 2010 bay pinto gelding Misty's Thunderstorm and a 2011 chestnut mare. She was later donated to the Chincoteague Pony Rescue who re-homed her.